- The entire Senate Republican conference vowing to resist the progressive campaign to expand the Supreme Court in a new letter to the justices.
- The GOP sent the letter after Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island alluded to the court-packing push in a legal brief he filed in a Second Amendment case currently before the Court.
- The Whitehouse brief accused the Court of pandering to powerful conservative interests. Republicans called the filing an “immediate threat” to the judiciary.
Senate Republicans urged the Supreme Court not to be intimidated after Democratic lawmakers warned that its decision in a pending Second Amendment case could inflame the liberal push to restructure the Court.
Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island filed an amicus (or “friend of the Court”) brief on Aug. 12 in a challenge to New York City’s gun transportation regulations that urged the high court to “heal itself before the public demands it be ‘restructured in order to reduce the influence of politics.’” Four other Democrats joined the Whitehouse brief.
While we remain members of this body, the Democrats’ threat to ‘restructure’ the Court is an empty one,” the Senate Republican conference wrote in a Thursday letter, which was first obtained by the Washington Post. “We share Justice Ginsburg’s view that ‘nine seems to be a good number.’ And it will remain that way as long as we are here.”
The justices agreed to decide on the constitutionality of New York City’s gun transportation rules in January. The city’s regulatory scheme restricted the movement of weapons to and from authorized shooting ranges. Licensed gun owners were forbidden from carrying their firearms beyond the five boroughs. The New York State Rifle and Pistol Association, which challenged the rules in court, believes those requirements violate the Second Amendment, the commerce clause, and the right to travel.
After the high court took the case, the city amended its ordinance to relax its transportation guidelines. City officials believe they have given the Association everything it sought in court, and are now urging the justices to dismiss the case as moot.
Whitehouse’s brief urged the justices to follow that course. In doing so, Whitehouse advanced a broad indictment of the Roberts court itself. He accused the conservative justices of bending procedural and jurisdictional rules to deliver victories for Republican political interests. Citing the 2018 Janus decision as an example, Whitehouse said the conservatives have used subtle language to encourage litigants to bring particular cases, or covertly overruled binding precedents but refusing to extend them to new areas. (RELATED: Liberal Justices Are Still Notching Victories Despite Conservative Supreme Court)